Samsung Electronics is baffled that its patent dispute with Apple (NASDAQ:AAPL) has led to a trial where the basic design of most rectangular smartphones is at issue, a senior Samsung executive said.

In an interview with Wired, which was conducted before the trial started Monday, Kevin Packingham, the chief product office for Samsung's mobile division, said that it is "defying common sense" that the patent debate has reached this point.

"In terms of patents, we have a made lot of contributions in the design space as well," he said. "I would say the patents we're struggling with--where there's a lot of discussion and litigation right now--are around these very broad design patents like a rectangle. For us, it's unreasonable that we're fighting over rectangles, that that's being considered as an infringement, which is why we're defending ourselves."

Apple has accused Samsung of "slavishly" copying the design of its iPhone and iPad, and has asserted design patents for both as well as the icon screens in its iOS software. Samsung is likely to argue in court that Apple's claims are too broad.

Packingham said that if the patent system is flawed, it is not Samsung's responsibility to fix it. "In general, this isn't a Samsung issue. This is an industry issue that we need to collectively solve," he said. "We are all trying to make sure that we are creating products and services that can be successful in the marketplace, and are interesting to consumers. So we need to find a way in which we can have healthy competition and not try to stifle competition with patents that aren't particularly unique, and really don't represent intellectual property."

In a jab at Apple, he said "there's just one company that's firing the first shot consistently. Most everybody else seems to be getting along really well."

During the first day of the trial, taking place in U.S. District Court in San Jose, Calif., the 10-member jury was selected. Opening arguments are expected on Tuesday.

For more:
- see this Wired article
- see this The Verge article
- see this AllThingsD article

Related Articles:
Apple, Samsung head to patent trial with billions on the line
Google: Motorola's patents worth $5.5B
Apple claims Samsung's patent infringement costs $2.5B in damages
Samsung's Galaxy Nexus pulled from Google Play store amid ban
Samsung fails to stop U.S. GalaxyTab 10.1 ban
Apple scores U.S. ban against Samsung's Galaxy Nexus



About Author

(2) Readers Comments

  1. I find the whole thing disheartening. They sound like politicians which in the USA mean ineffective, untruthful actors on the stage. There is no doubt there is a legal debate here, but to describe this as fighting over rectangles is deceptive. I do not know who will win, nor do I have a horse in the race but the fight would not have gotten here without more than rectangles and this executive knows it as the Google memo to them reinforces. Trade dress is a well established issue as is brand, patents and others. While we may not like it, the fault is in our poor IP and patent system. Business is about competition and gaining advantage so while we may not like what we see, the game is played as the rules lay out, and this is the result. If we do not like it, we need the law and rules changed. Meanwhile, I lose respect for firms and brands that are not truthful and in this case both sides are the losers.

  2. I think you have noted some very interesting details , thankyou for the post.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *